web analytics

Stealing Christmas from Pagans?

“Godless Mom” Courtney Heard posted a tired “attack” on the Christianness of Christmas: “Christmas is stolen from the Pagans”. To be clear: I have no problem should the dating of Christmas have been drawn from a non-Christian festival; I have no idea what date Jesus of Nazareth was born. It is even possible that birth dates weren’t remembered and celebrated in his culture – maybe Jesus didn’t even know what his birth day was.

Thanks Andrew Mark Henry for responding. This is the information I have shared previously:

I was pointed to an article, “Do the Gospels borrow from Pagan myths?“. It reminded me of the regular contention around this time that Christmas is essentially a pagan celebration. It’s usually said by a Christmas Grinch, or a Jehovah’s Witness, or someone with a particular agenda. The truth, possibly surprisingly, may be the other way around.

The Puritan-dominated Parliament of England in 1644 banned all Christmas activities as being unChristian. The Puritans of New England followed suit. Scholars aided the perception of the unChristian basis for Christmas.

Paul Ernst Jablonski (1693-1757) argued that the celebration of Christ’s birth on December 25th was one of the many “paganizations” of Christianity that the degenerating Church of the fourth century embraced, departing from the pure apostolic Christianity into Catholicism. On the other hand, Dom Jean Hardouin (1646 – 1729) argued that the Catholic Church adopted pagan festivals for Christian purposes without losing the purity of the gospel.

As an aside, if I had to side with one of those two positions, I would not share Jablonski’s fear of “paganism”. If the dating of Christmas in fact is proved to be of pagan origin – I will happily continue celebrating it.

But I have mentioned previously that the date of Christmas may have originated with a calculation of the date of the Incarnation based on the belief that this occurred on the same date as the crucifixion.

In the West the calculation of the crucifixion came up with 25 March; in the East 6 April. So that’s the date of the incarnation. Calculate 9 perfect months forward and you have a birth in the West 25 December, and in the East 6 January.

You can read more about this in Thomas J. Talley’s The Origins Of The Liturgical Year.

Professor William J. Tighe presses this further. He argues the opposite of the pagan origin of Christmas. He would have Christians already dating Christ’s birth as 25 December. Then the Roman Emperor Aurelian, hostile to Christianity, leading an empire that appeared to be collapsing in the face of internal unrest, rebellions in the provinces, economic decay, and repeated attacks from German tribes to the north and the Persian Empire to the east, and seeking to unify the various pagan cults of the Roman Empire, instituted the pagan festival of the “Birth of the Unconquered Sun” on 25 December 274. “If it co-opted the Christian celebration, so much the better.”

image source: Easter calendar years 532-632 A.D.

Similar Posts:

4 thoughts on “Stealing Christmas from Pagans?”

  1. I subscribe to the 9 months after the Incarnation, as did my teacher Marjorie Proctor-Smith.

    But so what if the Church was happy to also baptize Pagan holidays around the same time and adopt many of the celebratory traditions; trees, yule logs, mistletoe, etc. They make the festival all the more fun!

  2. It is of course highly improbable that Jesus was born in winter, but if we get fixated on when Jesus was born, we miss the point.

    Jesus was born.

    So the church decided to give Christians something to celebrate to distract them from the pagan midwinter feasts. Big deal. Like you… let’s celebrate God incarnate, God with us, Christ who could not have died for us if he had not been born.

    1. Thanks, Andy. And, yes, we need to help move the celebration from cute baby party towards the focus you mention: God incarnate; God with us. And then to the transformation this brings to us – we become children of God. Blessings.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Notify me of followup comments via e-mail. You can also subscribe without commenting.